1960 to Present
| Player | Position | Career AV | Games |
|---|---|---|---|
| John Elway | QB | 203 | 234 |
| Tom Nalen | C | 132 | 194 |
| Rod Smith | WR | 125 | 183 |
| Karl Mecklenburg | LB | 113 | 180 |
| Tom Jackson | LB | 109 | 191 |
| Louis Wright | CB | 109 | 166 |
| Randy Gradishar | LB | 107 | 145 |
| Bill Thompson | S | 106 | 179 |
| Dennis Smith | S | 98 | 184 |
| Champ Bailey | CB | 97 | 135 |