CarAV: 86

Frank Gore -- an original third-round pick -- would be the only player we should put above Sproles. After all, in 12 seasons, Gore has amassed 13,065 rushing yards, 74 rushing touchdowns and 90 total scores in 180 games.

The absolute best of Gore's many big-time seasons? His 2006 campaign with the San Francisco 49ers, during which he ran for 1,695 yards with an average of 5.4 yards per carry and 9 touchdowns, leading to an AV of 16.

For his sustained efforts, Gore boasts one Super Bowl appearance, eight playoff games and five Pro Bowls.