CarAV: 26

In contrast to Arrington, Cadillac Williams lasted seven seasons before hanging up the cleats in 2011. Accordingly, his AV is quite a jump from the depths of Arrington's.

Equipped with a bigger frame, Williams was made to withstand the everyday punishment of the game. Although, Williams' success came much earlier in his career. His best season was his rookie year when he rushed for 1,178 yards and six scores in 14 starts. He finished the year off with an AV of 8.

After that, Williams was on the decline. He never reached more than an AV of 6 nor did he rush for more than four touchdowns in any of his last six campaigns. For a top-five pick, he was a big disappointment for the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.