CarAV: 15

Since being drafted by the Carolina Panthers, Kelvin Benjamin has played just two seasons because of a torn ACL that caused him to miss the entirety of 2015. Nonetheless, he's provided solid production with 136 catches, 1,949 yards and 16 touchdowns through the age of 25.

The better of his two seasons was his first, when he posted an AV of 8 on the back of a 1,000-yard, 9-score season. Yet the 6'5" freak of an athlete has room for improvement -- he's caught a mere 51.7% of balls thrown his way.