AV: 16 | ANY/A: 6.07

Here, we transition into Favre's best seasons, at an AV of 16 or higher. And we start with a '98 campaign where he threw for 4,212 yards and 31 touchdowns in 16 starts. He even led the league with a completion percentage of 63%.

All this amounted to a rating of 87.8 and an 11-5 record for Wisconsin's favorite team. But, in spite of directing his cast to a playoff berth, there was no Pro Bowl bid for Favre.