CarAV: 113

You could say the Giants are happy with their acquisition of Eli Manning, but if they were to re-do it, they'd probably go with Ben Roethlisberger. Like Manning, Roethlisberger is a two-time Super Bowl winner, but has done one better with five Pro Bowl appearances in his 13 years.

Big Ben has spent the entirety of his NFL tenure with the Pittsburgh Steelers, winning 123 games in 183 starts while leading the team to nine playoff appearances. As a passer, he's tallied a total of 301 touchdowns on 64.1% passing and a 94.1 quarterback rating.

In his 2014 Pro Bowl campaign, Roethlisberger earned an AV of 15 -- the highest of his career. In that season, he tossed a career-high 32 touchdowns with just 9 picks in 16 starts. He also amassed a personal-best 4,952 yards as the Steelers went 11-5 under his command.